PJSK Character Tier List: Ranking The Best Written Characters

Hey guys! Let's dive into a character tier list for Project SEKAI: Colorful Stage! feat. Hatsune Miku (PJSK), but with a twist. We're not talking about gameplay or skills here. Instead, we're ranking characters based on how well-written they are. This is totally subjective, so please don't come at me with pitchforks if you disagree! We're here to have a fun discussion about character depth, development, and overall narrative contribution. This isn't about who's your favorite, but rather, who's story resonates the most and feels the most complete.

What Makes a Character "Well-Written"?

Before we jump into the tiers, let's quickly define what I mean by "well-written." For me, it boils down to a few key elements:

• Compelling Backstory: Does the character have a history that explains their present actions and motivations? Is it interesting and unique?
• Character Development: Do they grow and change throughout the story? Do they learn from their mistakes and experiences?
• Consistent Personality: Does their behavior feel consistent with their established traits? Are there any jarring inconsistencies?
• Relatable Flaws: Are they flawed individuals? Do they make mistakes? This makes them feel more human and relatable.
• Impact on the Narrative: How much do they contribute to the overall story? Do their actions have consequences?

These are just a few of the factors I considered while creating this tier list. Now, let's get to the ranking!

The Tier List

(Disclaimer: This is my personal opinion, and there will be spoilers ahead!)

S Tier: Masterfully Written

This tier is for the characters who are, in my opinion, the most compelling and well-developed in PJSK. They have complex backstories, significant character development, and a major impact on the overall narrative. These are the characters whose stories have truly resonated with me and left a lasting impression.

Let's start with Kanade Yoisaki from 25-ji, Nightcord de. Her story is a poignant exploration of survivor's guilt and the struggle to find meaning after loss. Kanade's dedication to creating music that can "save" someone, mirroring her own inability to save her friend, is both heartbreaking and inspiring. Her interactions with the other Nightcord members, particularly her slow opening up to Ena, are beautifully portrayed. Kanade's character arc is a masterclass in exploring mental health issues with sensitivity and nuance. Her past trauma is not just a plot device; it's a core part of who she is and shapes her every action. Her struggle with perfectionism, her fear of failure, and her deep-seated need to help others make her a deeply flawed yet incredibly sympathetic character. The gradual unraveling of her past, revealed through flashbacks and character interactions, keeps players invested in her journey. The writers have masterfully crafted a character whose motivations are clear, whose flaws are relatable, and whose development is both earned and satisfying.

Next, we have Shizuku Hinomori from MORE MORE JUMP!. Shizuku's journey is one of self-discovery and breaking free from expectations. As a former child actress, she's constantly pressured to maintain a perfect image, both by her agency and by her adoring fans. However, beneath the surface, she yearns for genuine connection and the freedom to express her true self. Her struggle to balance her public persona with her personal desires is a central theme in her story arc. Shizuku's complex relationship with her sister, Airi, adds another layer of depth to her character. The rivalry between them, born from professional jealousy and personal insecurities, is explored with remarkable sensitivity. Shizuku's ultimate decision to forge her own path, even if it means disappointing some people, is a testament to her growth and strength. Her quiet determination and unwavering loyalty to her friends make her a compelling and inspiring character. The nuances in her expressions and actions, often subtle yet powerful, further enhance the richness of her characterization. Shizuku's story is a reminder that true happiness comes from embracing your authentic self, even when it's difficult.

Finally, we can't forget Mafuyu Asahina, also from 25-ji, Nightcord de. Mafuyu's story is arguably the most tragic in PJSK. She's a character who has been molded into a "perfect" student by her overbearing mother, to the point where she's lost touch with her own emotions and desires. Her internal struggles, her constant feeling of emptiness, and her search for meaning are depicted with heartbreaking realism. Mafuyu's journey is a slow and painful process of self-discovery. She gradually begins to question the expectations placed upon her and to explore her own identity. Her interactions with the other Nightcord members, particularly Kanade, are crucial to her development. They provide her with a safe space to express her true feelings and to begin to heal. Mafuyu's story is a powerful commentary on the dangers of perfectionism and the importance of self-acceptance. Her vulnerability and her quiet strength make her a character that many players can empathize with. The writers have crafted a narrative that is both emotionally challenging and ultimately hopeful, showcasing the resilience of the human spirit.

A Tier: Excellent Characters

The A tier is reserved for characters who are exceptionally well-written, but perhaps lack the same level of depth or complexity as the S tier. They still have compelling stories, significant character development, and a notable impact on the narrative. These are characters that I greatly enjoy and appreciate.

Toya Aoyagi from Vivid BAD SQUAD stands out in this tier. His unwavering dedication to music and his desire to surpass his father's legacy are compelling motivations. His initial stoicism and reserved nature gradually give way to a more expressive and emotionally open personality as he interacts with his fellow Vivid BAD SQUAD members, particularly Akito. His backstory, involving his strained relationship with his father and his decision to pursue street music against his father's wishes, provides a solid foundation for his character. Toya's growth as a performer and as a person is a joy to watch. He learns to embrace his own unique style and to express his emotions through his music. His quiet determination and his unwavering loyalty to his friends make him a truly admirable character. The writers have done an excellent job of portraying his inner conflicts and his gradual transformation. Toya's journey is a testament to the power of perseverance and the importance of finding your own voice.

Another notable character in this tier is Ena Shinonome from 25-ji, Nightcord de. Ena's story revolves around her insecurities as an artist and her desperate need for validation. Her struggles with social media and her constant comparison of herself to others are highly relatable. Her prickly personality and her tendency to lash out at others often mask her own vulnerabilities. Ena's relationship with her father, a renowned artist, adds another layer of complexity to her character. Her desire to gain his approval and her fear of disappointing him drive much of her actions. Ena's growth throughout the story is subtle but significant. She gradually learns to accept her own flaws and to appreciate her own unique talents. Her interactions with the other Nightcord members, particularly Kanade, help her to confront her insecurities and to develop a stronger sense of self-worth. Ena's story is a powerful reminder that true validation comes from within and that it's okay to be imperfect. The writers have created a character that is both flawed and sympathetic, making her journey all the more compelling.

We also have Rui Kamishiro from Wonderlands x Showtime. Rui is a genius inventor and stage director, but he struggles with social interaction and often comes across as eccentric or even unsettling. His desire to create shows that evoke strong emotions in the audience stems from his own emotional detachment. Rui's backstory, involving his isolation and his passion for engineering, provides a clear understanding of his personality and his motivations. His interactions with the other Wonderlands x Showtime members, particularly Tsukasa, help him to connect with others on a deeper level. Rui's creativity and his willingness to push boundaries make him a fascinating character. He learns to balance his artistic vision with the needs and desires of his fellow performers. Rui's story is a celebration of individuality and the importance of finding your own way to connect with the world. The writers have crafted a character that is both quirky and endearing, making his journey a delightful one to follow.

B Tier: Good Characters

Characters in the B tier are well-written and enjoyable, but they may have some minor flaws or lack the depth of the characters in the higher tiers. They still contribute significantly to the story, but their arcs may be less impactful or memorable.

Akito Shinonome from Vivid BAD SQUAD fits comfortably in this tier. His competitive spirit and his desire to surpass his former partner are strong motivators. His initial arrogance and his tendency to clash with others gradually give way to a more collaborative and supportive attitude as he interacts with the other Vivid BAD SQUAD members. Akito's backstory, involving his past success and his subsequent setbacks, provides a good understanding of his competitive nature. His relationship with Toya is a central element of his character arc, and their dynamic is both engaging and believable. Akito's growth as a performer and as a person is well-portrayed. He learns to value teamwork and to appreciate the talents of others. While his story is compelling, it doesn't quite reach the same level of emotional depth as some of the characters in the higher tiers. The writers have done a solid job of crafting a character that is both flawed and admirable, but there's still room for further exploration of his inner world.

Another character in this tier is Nene Kusanagi from Wonderlands x Showtime. Nene is a talented singer and actress, but she's also incredibly shy and introverted. Her struggles with social anxiety and her reluctance to perform in front of large crowds are relatable. Nene's backstory, involving her past experiences with bullying and her passion for online gaming, provides a good understanding of her personality and her fears. Her interactions with the other Wonderlands x Showtime members, particularly Rui, help her to overcome her anxieties and to embrace her talents. Nene's growth as a performer is well-portrayed. She gradually gains confidence in her abilities and learns to enjoy the thrill of performing. While her story is heartwarming, it's not as complex or impactful as some of the other character arcs in the game. The writers have created a character that is both endearing and relatable, but there's potential for further development of her inner world and her relationships with others.

Finally, we have Kohane Azusawa from Vivid BAD SQUAD. Kohane's story is one of self-discovery and overcoming her shyness. Her initial lack of confidence and her fear of failure gradually give way to a more assertive and self-assured personality as she interacts with the other Vivid BAD SQUAD members. Kohane's desire to find her own voice and to express herself through music is a compelling motivator. Her interactions with An Shiraishi, her mentor and friend, are crucial to her development. Kohane's growth as a performer is well-portrayed. She learns to embrace her own unique style and to overcome her stage fright. While her story is inspiring, it's not as nuanced or emotionally complex as some of the other character arcs in the game. The writers have done a good job of crafting a character that is both relatable and inspiring, but there's still room for further exploration of her inner conflicts and her aspirations.

C Tier: Decent Characters

Characters in the C tier are still enjoyable, but their writing may be less consistent or their stories may be less impactful. They may have some underdeveloped aspects or rely on tropes more heavily than the characters in the higher tiers.

Tsukasa Tenma from Wonderlands x Showtime falls into this category. His unwavering optimism and his desire to become a world-famous star are admirable, but his personality can sometimes feel a bit one-dimensional. Tsukasa's backstory, involving his promise to his hospitalized sister, provides a good understanding of his motivations. However, his character arc is less focused on personal growth and more on his unwavering pursuit of his dream. Tsukasa's interactions with the other Wonderlands x Showtime members are entertaining, but they don't always lead to significant character development. While his enthusiasm and his determination are endearing, his story lacks the same level of emotional depth as some of the other character arcs in the game. The writers have created a character that is both energetic and inspiring, but there's potential for further exploration of his vulnerabilities and his inner struggles.

Another character in this tier is Minori Hanasato from MORE MORE JUMP!. Minori's unwavering dedication to her idol career and her determination to overcome her past failures are admirable. However, her personality can sometimes feel a bit generic, and her story arc is less focused on personal growth and more on her pursuit of her dream. Minori's admiration for Haruka Kiritani, her fellow MORE MORE JUMP! member, is a central element of her character, but their dynamic doesn't always feel as nuanced or compelling as some of the other relationships in the game. Minori's interactions with the other MORE MORE JUMP! members are enjoyable, but they don't always lead to significant character development. While her optimism and her hard work are inspiring, her story lacks the same level of emotional depth as some of the other character arcs in the game. The writers have created a character that is both relatable and inspiring, but there's potential for further exploration of her insecurities and her aspirations.

D Tier: Underdeveloped Characters

The D tier is for characters who I feel are underdeveloped or whose stories are less compelling. This doesn't necessarily mean they're bad characters, but they haven't resonated with me as much as the others. They may lack depth, have inconsistent writing, or simply not have enough screen time to fully develop.

Haruka Kiritani from MORE MORE JUMP! unfortunately lands in this tier. While she's a talented performer and a kind person, her story feels less developed than the other members of her group. Her past as a former popular idol and her desire to help Minori achieve her dreams are interesting, but they're not explored in as much depth as they could be. Haruka's interactions with the other MORE MORE JUMP! members are enjoyable, but they don't always lead to significant character development. Her personality is consistent, but it also feels somewhat limited. The writers could have delved deeper into her motivations and her inner struggles. Haruka's story has potential, but it hasn't been fully realized in my opinion.

An Shiraishi from Vivid BAD SQUAD also falls into this category. While she's a talented performer and a strong leader, her story feels less nuanced than some of the other characters in Vivid BAD SQUAD. Her desire to surpass her father's legacy and her passion for street music are compelling motivations, but they're not explored in as much depth as they could be. An's interactions with the other Vivid BAD SQUAD members are enjoyable, but they don't always lead to significant character development. Her personality is consistent, but it also feels somewhat predictable. The writers could have explored her vulnerabilities and her inner conflicts more fully. An's story is enjoyable, but it hasn't resonated with me as much as the other character arcs in her group.

E Tier: Least Well-Written Characters

This is the bottom tier, reserved for characters who I feel are the least well-written in PJSK. This doesn't mean they're terrible characters, but their stories may be bland, inconsistent, or simply not very engaging. They may serve a purpose in the narrative, but they don't leave a lasting impression.

I'm hesitant to put anyone in this tier, as I think all the PJSK characters have some redeeming qualities. However, if I had to choose, I would place Saki Tenma from Leo/need here. Saki's story revolves around her illness and her desire to reconnect with her childhood friends. While her illness is a significant part of her backstory, it doesn't always feel like it's driving her character development in a meaningful way. Her interactions with the other Leo/need members are sweet, but they don't always lead to significant character growth. Saki's personality is cheerful and optimistic, but it can also feel a bit simplistic. The writers could have delved deeper into her inner struggles and her fears. Saki's story is heartwarming, but it hasn't resonated with me as much as the other character arcs in the game. She serves primarily as a catalyst for the other members' growth, rather than having a compelling arc of her own.

F Tier: Not Applicable

This tier is for characters that are either minor, have no significant impact on the story, or whose writing is so minimal that they cannot be fairly assessed. There are no characters in PJSK that I would definitively place in this tier.

Final Thoughts

So, there you have it! My personal PJSK character tier list based on writing quality. Remember, this is just my opinion, and I'm sure many of you will disagree. That's perfectly fine! I encourage you to share your own thoughts and opinions in the comments below. Let's have a respectful discussion about the characters we love and the stories that resonate with us. Ultimately, the beauty of PJSK lies in its diverse cast of characters and their unique journeys. Whether you agree with my rankings or not, I hope this has sparked some thought and appreciation for the writing in this amazing game. Don't forget to tell me what you guys think!